Evaluation of Eulerian and Lagrangian Method in Analysis of Concrete Gravity Dam Including Dam Water Foundation Interaction
Because of the reservoir effect, dynamic analysis of concrete dams is more involved than other common structures. This problem is mostly sourced by the differences between reservoir water, dam body and foundation material behaviors. To account for the reservoir effect in dynamic analysis of concrete gravity dams, two methods are generally employed. Eulerian method in reservoir modeling gives rise to a set of coupled equations, whereas in Lagrangian method, the same equations for dam and foundation structure are used. The Purpose of this paper is to evaluate and study possible advantages and disadvantages of both methods. Specifically, application of the above methods in the analysis of dam-foundationreservoir systems is leveraged to calculate the hydrodynamic pressure on dam faces. Within the frame work of dam- foundationreservoir systems, dam displacement under earthquake for various dimensions and characteristics are also studied. The results of both Lagrangian and Eulerian methods in effects of loading frequency, boundary condition and foundation elasticity modulus are quantitatively evaluated and compared. Our analyses show that each method has individual advantages and disadvantages. As such, in any particular case, one of the two methods may prove more suitable as presented in the results section of this study.
 Westergaard H.M ,"Water pressure on Dams during Earthquakes", ASCE , 1931
 tsubo , S.,"Dynamic Water Pressure on Dam due to Irregular Earthquakes " Memoirs Faculty of Engineering , Kyushu University , Fukuoka , Japan , Vol. 18 ,No. 4 , 1959
 Brahtz, H. A., and Heilborn, C. H., discussion of "Water Pressure on
Dams during Earthquakes," by H. M. Westergaard, Transactions, ASCE,
Vol. 98, 1933
 Hoskins, L. M., and Jacobsen, L. S., Water Pressure in a Tank Caused by Simulated Earthquake," Bulletin, Seismological Society of America,
Vol. 24, No. Jan.,1934
 Werner, P. W., and Sundquist, K. J., "On Hydrodynamic Earthquike
Effects," Transactions, American Geophysical Union, Vol. 30, No. 5, Oct., 1949
 Bustamante J. I., Rosenblueth, E., Herrera, I., and Flores, A., "Presion
hidrodynamica en presas y depositos, " Boletin Sociedad Mexicana de Ingenieria Sismica. Vol. 1, No. 2, Oct., 1963
 Zangar , C. N., "Hydrodynamic Pressures on Dams due to Horizontal
Earthquake Effects," Engineering Monograph No. 11, U. S. Bureau of
Reclamation, May , 1959
 Kotsubo, S., "External Forces on Arch Dams during Earthquakes,"
Memories Faculty of Engineering, Kyushu Univercity , Fukuoka, Japan,
Vol. 20,No. 4, 1961
 Chopra A. K. ,Chakrabarti P., "Hydrodynamic Pressures And Response
of Gravity Dams to Vertical Earthquake Component ", E.E. & D.D. Vol. 1, 1973
 Chopra A.K., Chakrabarti P., Gupta S. "Earthquake Response of
Concrete Gravity Dams Including Hydrodynamic And Foundation
Interaction Effects", Report No. UCB / EERC - 80/01 January 1980.
 Navaye nia B, "Hydrodynamic analysis of Gravity Dam-reservoir system
with lagrangian method ", M.S thesis, mir Kabir university of
 Wilson E. L., Khalvati M., "Finite Elements for Dynamic Analysis of
Fluid-Solid Systems", Int., J. Num. Meth. Eng. Vol. 19, 1983.
 Alijamshidi D, Navaye nia B, Vaseghi J, "Dynamic analysis of Concrete
Gravity Dams with Eulerian and Lagrangian method",1997.
 Ahmadi M T, Gharebaghi B, "Earthquake analysis of Concrete Gravity
Dams Including Hydrodynamic Interaction Effects with Eulerian method", International Institute Of Earthquake Engineering and